2509.14555v1
Stratified wind from a super-Eddington X-ray binary is slower than expected
XRISM collaboration, Marc Audard</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hisamitsu Awaki</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Ralf Ballhausen</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Aya Bamba</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Ehud Behar</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Rozenn Boissay-Malaquin</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Laura Brenneman</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Gregory V. Brown</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Lia Corrales</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Elisa Costantini</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Renata Cumbee</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Maria Diaz Trigo</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Chris Done</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Durham-CEA, UK</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Tadayasu Dotani</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Ken Ebisawa</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Megan Eckart</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Dominique Eckert</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Teruaki Enoto</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Satoshi Eguchi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yuichiro Ezoe</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Adam Foster</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Ryuichi Fujimoto</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yutaka Fujita</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yasushi Fukazawa</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Kotaro Fukushima</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Akihiro Furuzawa</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Luigi Gallo</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Javier A. Garcia</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Liyi Gu</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Matteo Guainazzi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Kouichi Hagino</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Kenji Hamaguchi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Isamu Hatsukade</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Katsuhiro Hayashi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Takayuki Hayashi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Natalie Hell</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Edmund Hodges-Kluck</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Ann Hornschemeier</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yuto Ichinohe</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Manabu Ishida</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Kumi Ishikawa</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yoshitaka Ishisaki</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Jelle Kaastra</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Timothy Kallman</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Erin Kara</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Satoru Katsuda</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yoshiaki Kanemaru</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Richard Kelley</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Caroline Kilbourne</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Shunji Kitamoto</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Shogo Kobayashi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Takayoshi Kohmura</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Aya Kubota</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Maurice Leutenegger</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Michael Loewenstein</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yoshitomo Maeda</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Maxim Markevitch</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hironori Matsumoto</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Kyoko Matsushita</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Dan McCammon</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Brian McNamara</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Francois Mernier</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Eric D. Miller</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Jon M. Miller</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Ikuyuki Mitsuishi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Misaki Mizumoto</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Fukuoka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Tsunefumi Mizuno</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Koji Mori</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Koji Mukai</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hiroshi Murakami</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Richard Mushotzky</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hiroshi Nakajima</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Kazuhiro Nakazawa</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Jan-Uwe Ness</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Kumiko Nobukawa</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Masayoshi Nobukawa</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hirofumi Noda</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hirokazu Odaka</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Shoji Ogawa</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Anna Ogorzalek</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Takashi Okajima</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Naomi Ota</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Stephane Paltani</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Robert Petre</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Paul Plucinsky</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Frederick Scott Porter</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Katja Pottschmidt</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Kosuke Sato</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Toshiki Sato</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Makoto Sawada</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hiromi Seta</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Megumi Shidatsu</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Aurora Simionescu</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Randall Smith</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hiromasa Suzuki</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Andrew Szymkowiak</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hiromitsu Takahashi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Mai Takeo</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Toru Tamagawa</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Keisuke Tamura</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Takaaki Tanaka</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Atsushi Tanimoto</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Makoto Tashiro</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yukikatsu Terada</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yuichi Terashima</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yohko Tsuboi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Masahiro Tsujimoto</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hiroshi Tsunemi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Takeshi G. Tsuru</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Aysegul Tumer</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hiroyuki Uchida</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Nagomi Uchida</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yuusuke Uchida</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hideki Uchiyama</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Yoshihiro Ueda</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Shinichiro Uno</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Jacco Vink</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Shin Watanabe</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Brian J. Williams</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Satoshi Yamada</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Shinya Yamada</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Hiroya Yamaguchi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Kazutaka Yamaoka</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Noriko Yamasaki</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Makoto Yamauchi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Shigeo Yamauchi</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Tahir Yaqoob</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Tomokage Yoneyama</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Tessei Yoshida</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Mihoko Yukita</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Irina Zhuravleva</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Joey Neilsen</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Villanova, USA</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Ryota Tomaru</name> <arxiv:affiliation>Osaka, Japan</arxiv:affiliation> </author> <author> <name>Missagh Mehdipour
Digest
XRISM/Resolve’s 2024-02-25 spectrum of the neutron-star binary GX 13+1 reveals a stratified, highly ionised, Compton-thick wind via dozens of narrow, slightly blueshifted lines from Si–Ni, including high-order Fe XXV/XXVI features above 7 keV. Photoionisation fits require a slow, very dense absorber plus a faster (~700 km/s), more ionised layer to reproduce the Fe XXVI Ly blue wing and residual core flux from wind reprocessing. After correcting for electron-scattering attenuation, the intrinsic luminosity is at or above Eddington, yet the outflow is extremely slow, favouring a thermal‑radiative outer-disc origin over an inner-disc radiation‑pressure (Eddington) wind. The contrast with ultrafast (~0.3c) SMBH winds at similar Eddington ratios points to fundamentally different launch mechanisms across mass scales.
Key figures to inspect
- Fig. 1 (Resolve spectrum): Inspect the forest of narrow H‑ and He‑like lines (Si–Ni) and the high‑order Fe XXV/XXVI transitions >7 keV; their small oscillator strengths yet large depths diagnose an extreme column and confirm the absorber is Compton‑thick while only slightly blueshifted.
- Fig. 2 (Historical variability): Compare the XRISM-coordinated NuSTAR spectrum with archival NuSTAR/RXTE; the unusually deep Fe XXV K edge at 8.8 keV and reduced flux identify the rare dense‑wind state (seen in only ~5–10% of RXTE epochs), while the blue band shows the intrinsic super‑Eddington continuum after τ_es co…
- Fig. 3 (Fe K zoom): The non‑black line cores require diffuse reprocessed/scattered emission from the wind, and the Fe XXVI Ly blue wing demands a faster (~700 km/s), broader (~300 km/s), more ionised component layered over the slow dense flow—direct evidence for wind stratification.
- Extended Data Fig. 5 (Ion fractions): The Fe ion balance shows only ~10% of Fe resides in Fe XXVI at the best‑fit ionisation, implying the fast-zone column is a lower limit because most Fe is fully stripped.
Tags
- obscured AGN
- super-Eddington
- X-ray
- spectroscopy